Should I invest or pay off my mortgage: Which Strategy Works Best?

If you regularly have surplus liquidity income at the end of the month, a common question is whether to allocate it towards reducing your mortgage balance or to invest it. Both approaches can improve your long-term financial position, but the right choice depends on factors such as interest rates, your risk tolerance, and overall financial goals.

How a Mortgage Loan Works

A mortgage is a long-term loan secured against a property, most commonly used to buy a home. The lender releases the funds to your solicitor at completion, allowing you to purchase the property, and in return you agree to repay the loan, plus interest, over an agreed term (typically 15 to 30 years).

Monthly mortgage payments usually consist of two parts:

• Interest, the cost of borrowing the money.
• Principal, the repayment of the amount borrowed.

For example, if your monthly repayment is £1,000, a portion will cover interest while the remainder reduces the outstanding balance. Early in the mortgage term, payments are weighted more heavily towards interest because the loan balance is larger. Over time, as the balance reduces, a greater share of each payment goes towards repaying the principal.

Mortgage rates in the UK vary depending on the Bank of England base rate, wider market conditions, and your credit profile. Borrowers may choose between fixed-rate mortgages, where payments remain the same for a set period, or variable-rate mortgages, which can change in line with interest rate movements.

Understanding how mortgage payments are structured is key when deciding whether to make overpayments or to invest surplus income elsewhere.

Pay Off Your Mortgage Early Vs. Investing

When deciding between overpaying your mortgage or investing spare cash, the right choice depends on interest rates, investment costs and your wider financial planning. Many people find that reducing debt provides certainty, while investing offers the possibility of higher long-term returns but with added risk.

Just like with renting vs buying, in most cases, it makes more sense to buy and pay off your debts, especially high-interest debts like credit card bills or mortgages rather than re-investing extra liquidity into the market.

Why Paying Off Your Mortgage Can Make Sense

• Debt reduction first: It is often difficult for investments to reliably outperform the interest charged on your mortgage, particularly once fees are considered. Overpayments provide a guaranteed return by cutting future interest costs.
• Peace of mind: Being mortgage-free earlier offers financial security and flexibility in later life.
• Lower overall cost: The sooner you reduce your balance, the less you will pay in total interest over the mortgage term.

When Investing Could Be Attractive

• Potential for higher growth: Investments in a Stocks and Shares ISA or pension could outperform mortgage rates over the long term.
• Tax efficiency: ISAs provide tax-free growth and withdrawals, while pensions offer tax relief on contributions and, often, employer top-ups.
• Flexibility: Some accounts allow you to access funds if needed, though penalties may apply with certain products.

Focus on cost

Investment charges, such as platform fees, fund management costs and early withdrawal penalties, can significantly reduce returns. Since mortgage overpayments are cost-free (beyond any lender overpayment limits), they often provide a clearer, more predictable benefit. If you do invest, choosing tax-efficient accounts like ISAs can help improve your net returns.

Benefits of Paying Off Your Mortgage Early

• Lower total interest: Reduces the overall cost of borrowing, especially valuable if your mortgage rate is high.
• Financial freedom: Clears debt sooner and provides peace of mind.
• Certainty of return: Unlike investments, the savings on interest are guaranteed.

Drawbacks of Paying Off Your Mortgage Early

• Opportunity cost: Money used to repay the mortgage cannot be invested, so you may miss potential market growth.
• Early repayment charges: Some lenders apply penalties if you overpay beyond their allowance, particularly within the first few years.
• Reduced flexibility: Once funds are tied up in the property, they are harder to access in case of emergencies.

Repay (or pay off) mortgage or invest: what should I choose?

As a general guideline, you should prioritize paying off debt with higher interest rates before debt with lower interest rates. A credit card or private student loan may have a higher interest rate than your mortgage, so paying those off sooner might be more advantageous.

But be careful not to make mortgage payments fall behind your higher-interest debt payments. Yes, credit cards can be pricey, and if you don’t make your payments on time, the card issuer might sue you. However, skipping a mortgage payment can be more worse because you run the danger of losing your house.

Consider your financial goals

When deciding whether to invest or overpay your mortgage, start by clarifying your objectives: is it to save up to buy another house in the future, pay for a future holiday, or is it something longer term? 

Depending on when you need the money should help shape how much risk you are prepared to take. The longer you plan to invest the higher the risk you can take. With risk comes the opportunity for greater returns but also the chance for greater losses. You can consider investing in property as a way of generating additional income with less risk. Alternative property investments or UK REIT ETFs can be a good option in that regard.

Individuals need to ensure they get the advice they need. Digital wealth managers, like Moneyfarm, help you to understand your investor profile based on your attitude to risk, knowledge of financial instruments and personal circumstances. Based on your investor profile you are assigned an investment portfolio and historic returns can be seen for each of these.

Your mortgage should not stop you from saving, many individuals have these throughout their working lives. Investing regularly can be a good way to grow wealth over time and doing this in a flexible account such as the ISA allows for life changes. Ultimately the decision to invest or pay off your mortgage depends on how comfortable you are holding debt and your appetite for risk.

Key Takeaways

• Overpaying your mortgage reduces debt and guarantees savings on interest.
• Investing offers potential long-term growth but carries market risk.
• Tax-efficient accounts such as ISAs and pensions can enhance investment returns.
• Consider your goals, time horizon and risk tolerance before deciding.
• Mortgage debt does not prevent you from investing, but balance is key.
• Professional financial advice can help align your decision with your long-term plan.

FAQ