Are ISAS worth it in 2026? Why choose investment ISAs or Cash ISAs

Saving or investing in an ISA (Individual Savings Account) in the UK can significantly impact how much tax you pay on your savings. But with the introduction of the Personal Savings Allowance, many people are asking: are ISAs worth it in 2026?

The answer isn’t always straightforward. Whether an ISA is the right choice for you depends on your financial goals, how much you have saved, and your income tax bracket. Let’s explore when an ISA makes sense and how to choose the right one for your circumstances.

The Personal Savings Allowance Explained

The Personal Savings Allowance (PSA) is the amount of interest you can earn on your savings in regular, non-ISA accounts without paying tax. The size of your allowance depends on your income tax rate:

• £1,000 of tax-free interest for basic-rate (20%) taxpayers.
• £500 of tax-free interest for higher-rate (40%) taxpayers.
• £0 for additional-rate (45%) taxpayers.

With interest rates on savings accounts having risen, more people are finding that the interest they earn now exceeds their PSA. This is where ISAs become particularly valuable. Any interest, dividends, or capital gains generated within an ISA are completely free from UK tax, regardless of how much you earn.

A PSA applies to interest earned from various sources, including bank and building society accounts, credit union accounts, and government bonds. For additional-rate taxpayers, an ISA is the only way to earn interest on savings without paying tax.

Is an ISA Worth It for Higher-Rate Taxpayers?

Yes, absolutely. If you are a higher-rate or additional-rate taxpayer, an ISA is a crucial tool for tax-efficient saving and investing. As a higher-rate taxpayer, once you exceed your £500 PSA, you’ll lose 40% of any further interest to tax. For additional-rate taxpayers, all interest earned outside an ISA is taxed at 45%.

By using an ISA, you keep 100% of your returns. The more your money grows, the more you save in tax. This makes ISAs an essential consideration for anyone looking to build wealth effectively over the long term, especially if their savings are generating significant interest.

Key Benefits of Using an ISA

Beyond the headline tax benefits, ISAs offer several other advantages that make them a cornerstone of sound financial planning.

ISAs are Flexible

Many providers now offer flexible ISAs. This feature allows you to withdraw money from your ISA and repay it within the same tax year without it affecting your £20,000 annual allowance. This can be very useful if you need to access your money for an unexpected expense. Always check with your provider, as not all ISAs offer this feature.

ISA Allowances Can Be Inherited

Since 2015, married couples and civil partners can inherit each other’s ISA allowance. The surviving partner receives an ‘additional permitted subscription’ (APS) equivalent to the value of the deceased partner’s ISA at the time of their death. This is on top of their own annual £20,000 allowance, allowing them to shelter more money from tax.

Cash ISA vs. Stocks and Shares ISA

The question of whether an ISA is worth it often comes down to which type you’re considering. The two most common types serve very different purposes.

Cash ISAs

A Cash ISA is essentially a tax-free savings account. It’s ideal for short-term goals (1-3 years), building an emergency fund, or for savers who are risk-averse. The returns are predictable, based on an interest rate, and your capital is not at risk. However, the main drawback is that interest rates may not always keep pace with inflation, meaning the purchasing power of your money could decrease over time.

Stocks and Shares ISAs

A Stocks and Shares ISA, or Investment ISA, allows you to invest in a range of assets like funds, shares, and bonds. This type of ISA is designed for long-term financial objectives (at least 5 years), as it gives your money the potential to grow significantly more than in a cash account.

While a Stocks and Shares ISA offers the potential to outpace inflation and grow your wealth over time, it comes with risk. The value of your investments can go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested. It’s crucial to be comfortable with this risk and have a long-term perspective.

Would ISAs Still Be Recommended with Inflation?

With inflation being a key concern for savers, choosing the right account is more important than ever. While top cash rates can sometimes match or beat inflation, this is not always guaranteed, especially if interest rates fall.

A Cash ISA can protect your interest from tax, but it may not protect your capital’s buying power from inflation. For long-term goals, a diversified Stocks and Shares ISA remains one of the most effective ways to generate real, after-inflation growth. Historically, stock markets have delivered returns that significantly outperform both inflation and cash savings over the long run, though past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Transferring Your ISA

If you’re unhappy with your current ISA’s interest rate, fees, or investment options, you can transfer it to a new provider. Research shows many people are unaware they can move their ISA savings to get a better deal.

It’s vital to use the official ISA transfer process. Do not simply withdraw the money and pay it into a new account, as this will cause your savings to lose their tax-free status and will count towards your current year’s allowance. A transfer preserves the tax wrapper for all the funds you’ve built up over previous years.

FAQ