Posted in:

Should I invest in a LISA or a Pension?

The Lifetime ISA is designed to help people save for their first home or retirement, but with its added government bonus, should you be investing in a LISA or a pension?

What is a Lifetime ISA (LISA)?

The Lifetime ISA (LISA) wrapper works just like a stocks and shares ISA, any money you put in the ISA can grow tax-free for as long as it’s in there.

If you’re under the age of 40, you can opt to put up to £4,000 in your LISA each year and receive a 25% top-up from the government – that’s £1,000 if you’ve invested the full amount.

Although the LISA is more generous than the Help to Buy ISA, it’s been controversial due to its plans to penalise savers who might need to access their cash early. The savings pot can only be used to buy a first home or for retirement from the age of 60, otherwise it’s locked-up.

If you need to access your money for something else, you’re charged 25% of the amount you withdraw as a penalty. This means you would get less than you had initially put in if you access your money early.

Whilst you might be saving for retirement, the complicated LISA isn’t a specific pensions product.

After recent pension freedoms saw exit charges reduce to 1%, the 25% charge looks a massive disadvantage, especially when you can usually take 25% of your pension as a tax-free lump sum at 55.

The current government contributions to pension savings are more generous for higher and additional rate taxpayers.

Tax benefits of a pension

The tax benefits to investing in a personal pension are generous. When you invest into your pension, you can claim tax relief on your contributions relative to your income tax band.

You can usually get the basic rate of tax relief automatically added to your pension contributions with your pension provider, which means you only have to pay £8,000 for a £10,000 contribution. This is the same as getting £200,000 tax relief on a pension pot worth £1 million, which is the equivalent to a 25% boost in your savings.

You can claim back more through HMRC if you’re a higher or additional rate taxpayer. This adjustment is usually reflected in your tax band.  

Personal pension wrappers act a lot like ISA wrappers. Any investments that you keep in here can grow protected from tax, although you may be required to pay tax on some of your pension when you withdraw it.

Tax benefits when you withdraw your pension

Once you reach the age of 55, you can withdraw a quarter of your pension tax-free.  You’ll pay income tax on the remainder, whether you decide to take an annuity, enter income drawdown, or take lump sums.

You decide what to do with your tax-free lump sum, but it’s important you don’t waste it because once it’s gone, it’s gone.

The age you can access your personal pension raises to 57 in 2028, so it’s important you do what you can today to secure your financial future.

Sign up to receive the Moneyfarm newsletter

Get the latest news and tips for managing your finances, straight to your inbox.

By making an investment, your capital is at risk.

If you have no need for a big lump sum, you can choose to take your tax-relief through your withdrawals. As you won’t have taken your tax-free lump sum, this is known as an uncrystallised funds pension lump sum (UFPLS).

If you withdraw £10,000 from your pension, for example, £2,500 will be tax free. The remainder will be taxed at your marginal rate of income tax.

Inheritance tax

This can be good in terms of inheritance, as no inheritance tax is charged on a pension. If you withdraw your tax-free lump-sum this may be counted as part of your estate, which could increase the inheritance tax bill your loved ones have to pay.

If you die before the age of 75, your pension will be passed on completely tax-free to your beneficiaries. A lifetime allowance check will be made on uncrystallised funds. If you’re over 75 when you die, your beneficiary will be charged their marginal rate of income tax on your pension savings.

Whilst you may be eligible for higher rate tax relief whilst you’re contributing to your pension, you may be charged just the basic tax rate in retirement, which will give your savings an extra little boost.

Can you have a LISA and a pension?

Essentially, the LISA wasn’t designed as a pension replacement; you have to wait longer to access your pension, pay higher exit charges, and could get less generous tax relief.

The two can be used together as a part of reliable financial planning, however. If you’re a higher or additional rate taxpayer and you’ve exhausted your annual pension allowance, investing in a LISA could help boost your retirement income more than in a stocks and shares ISA alone thanks to the government bonus.

Make sure you understand all the rules around investing in a LISA before you start. At Moneyfarm, we advocate the benefits of long-term investing, we don’t want to penalise those who need to access their money early. Knowing your investments balance risk and return is one thing; knowing you’ll get less than you put in if you’re forced to use it early is quite another.

Remember your annual ISA allowance is £20,000. If you do invest the full £4,000 in a LISA, you will still have capacity to invest in a stocks and shares ISA afterwards.

The future of the LISA could be under threat, however, after the Treasury Select Committee recommended the government abolish the LISA, saying it is too complex and not popular with savers.

Whilst there’s no idea if this recommendation will be taken, or if it is when it will come into effect, but it’s important to make the most of the schemes available to you to maximise your income throughout retirement.

Moneyfarm Pension

The Moneyfarm Pension is a personal pension plan designed to give you financial security throughout retirement.

As one of the first digital wealth managers to offer regulated investment advice, we’re committed to bringing advice to more people and changing the relationship people have with their investments.

We provide a unique combination of investment advice and discretionary management to help people grow their wealth over time.

Try MoneyFarm for free


Simple, efficient and tailored to your profile. The MoneyFarm investment plan maximises your long-term returns whilst protecting your wealth.

Sign up to MoneyFarm now: get access to your investor profile and discover the portfolio that is right for you, free of charge.

Get started